My favorite signs to collect are old route shields, guide signs, markers and so forth from New Jersey, New York and (someday) Pennsylvania. I’m not as interested in regulation signs like STOP or KEEP RIGHT, unless there’s something unique going on with it. I’m doing my best to resist the urge to go down the “get signs from all 50 states” rabbit hole.
- Cast Iron Guide Sign (Union County, NJ, 1920s)
- Cast Aluminum NJ State 27 Highway Shield (1927 spec)
- Porcelain NYC Humpback Street Sign
- Steel New York State Route 439 Shield
- Embossed Porcelain Hunterdon County Route 512 Shield
- Porcelain Public Service Bus Station Marker
- Garden State Parkway Shield (1962)
- Other Signs
Cast Iron Guide Sign (Union County, NJ, 1920s)
After years of searching, in 2017 I finally found a cast iron NJ guide sign that had dodged the scrap heap. An eBay seller listed it with a fairly high price. I waited patiently over a couple months for him to realize that my offer was decent and we eventually made a deal.
Deducing from old Union County maps, this sign was probably located in New Providence Township (present-day Berkeley Heights), where Glenside Avenue and Glenside Road used to come to a fork before the construction of I-78. Drivers approaching the fork from Summit would bear right to climb the hill to New Providence borough, or bear left toward Scotch Plains and Plainfield. The fork was adjacent to the entrance to the Deserted Village in the Watchung Reservation.
The sign only measures 18″ x 24″, but weighs a very hefty 57 pounds!
Guide signs like this were still around in decent numbers when I was a kid, but only a handful are left in the state today (e.g., Cranbury in Middlesex County still maintains a few of them). You can still spot quite a few of the original posts hanging around, if you look hard enough.
The photo carousel above documents the stages of preparation and painting from the sign’s “lead paint chip dispenser” stage (sic, Ed Tapanes) to the finished product. I initially used a wire brush, then applied Soy Gel stripper and removed loose paint with a scraper and awl. I sprayed the white coats then used a sponge brush for the raised lettering. I elected not to sand blast the sign to avoid any possible blunting of the edges of the letters.
Cast Aluminum NJ State Highway 27 Shield (1927 spec)
From the 1927 State Highway specification, this 16″ round aluminum NJ State Highway 27 shield came to me in really nice condition, with no need for restoration. Route 27 used to extend from Newark to Trenton, but its southern terminus is now in Princeton. Like the cast iron guide sign I have, these early NJ State Highway shields seem to be scarce as hens’ teeth.
Porcelain NYC Humpback Street Sign
This sign from the corner of Eleanor Roosevelt’s Greenwich Village apartment at Washington Square North & MacDougal was probably manufactured in the 1910s or ’20s. It did not come to me in its original frame, so I placed it in a frame of similar vintage that was retired from Easton, PA. I think these cobalt blue signs look very graceful, and I love the font, especially the way the points of the “W” and “N” extend ever so slightly below the base line.
Steel New York State Route 439 Shield (1957)
In my book, New York has one of the cooler-looking state highway shields, and I’m delighted to have an example in my collection. This particular shield, dated June 1957, comes from the last generation of cut-out NY shields; made in between the embossed shield era and the modern, rectangular shield era.
NY Route 439 formerly extended from the Goethals Bridge across Staten Island via Forest Avenue to the Staten Island Ferry, and continued in Brooklyn a short distance to the Belt Parkway. It was discontinued in 1968, soon after the Verrazano Bridge was constructed, when ferry routes between Staten Island and Brooklyn were terminated and most cross-island traffic flowed to the bridge via the Staten Island Expressway.
Embossed Porcelain Hunterdon County Route 512 Shield
Porcelain on embossed steel, circa 1950. Hunterdon County Route 512 is still a very scenic drive today. I love these early embossed county route shields, and I’d really like to find a Passaic County example someday.
Porcelain Public Service Bus Station Marker
Once ubiquitous around the state, these 1940s (?) bus station markers with their cool graphics are sort of a New Jersey icon. I remember one of these was posted around the corner from our house at least into the 1980s.
Garden State Parkway Shield (1962)
I don’t own this GSP shield any longer, but it was a cool addition to my collection while I had it. It came with writing on the back by traffic engineer J. A. Artale, dated 9/13/62. I did not know this writing was even there until I actually had the shield in hand. It is an interesting bit of historical context.
My other signs on display include:
- Welcome to Clifton (NJ) shield that I believe was posted a mile from the house I grew up in. Thanks, Ed Tapanes!
- Stop When Flashing sign: I’m not sure where I got this. It appears to have been part of a railroad crossing or entrance gate.
- NJ Route 28 Shield (24″ x 24″): I snagged this from my neighbor’s trash several years back. According to sign expert Steve Alpert, this sign can be likely dated to the 1980s by the NJDT printed in the lower right corner.
- Great Falls signs from Paterson: These were a neat bonus thrown in with the signal from Main & Market that I obtained in 2019.